Association Events
Learn about NHADA's major events and fundraisers.
Print this article
Assessing Store Performance and Market Position
Every transaction begins with a thorough review of store performance. Buyers should obtain and review factory statements to evaluate normalized earnings, departmental profitability, fixed absorption, and inventory turn. Additionally, buyers should review a sample of deal jackets to ensure compliance and proper funding as well as service and warranty claims. Inadequate support can indicate an increase in OEM audit risk and exposure issues when the stock of a seller is acquired or sold. Getting ahead of any potential documentation issues can assist in making the transition process smoother. Sellers must present accurate financials that reflect ongoing operations rather than unusual or nonrecurring items. Transparency builds confidence and supports efficient negotiations.
Market position is equally important. Brand strength, competitive saturation, and demographic trends influence valuation expectations. Sellers should understand how their market position affects goodwill, while buyers must determine whether the franchise aligns with their strategic objectives. Realistic assumptions from the outset help avoid delays and renegotiations.
Valuation and Deal Structure
Dealership value rests on tangible assets and intangible goodwill, or blue sky. Brand multiples serve as reference points, but actual value reflects operational results and expectations, customer mix, facility condition, and market outlook. Well-supported valuations grounded in financial data reduce the likelihood of post-closing disputes.
Deal structure significantly affects tax consequences and liability considerations. Asset sales allow buyers to step up the tax basis of acquired assets and limit exposure to historical liabilities. Sellers may prefer stock sales for potential tax advantages and administrative simplicity. Detailed modeling of after-tax outcomes helps both parties evaluate purchase price allocations, depreciation opportunities, and available elections.
Real Estate and Facility Requirements
Dealership transactions often involve real estate held separately from the operating entity, creating distinct negotiations around lease terms, purchase options, and facility requirements. Buyers must determine whether the property meets OEM standards and evaluate the scope and cost of required upgrades. Sellers should weigh the benefits of retaining the real estate as a long-term investment against the simplicity of selling both the business and property together.
Working Capital, Inventory, and Floorplan Considerations
Working capital definitions are central to a dealership transaction. Buyers must confirm working capital will sustain operations, while sellers need to ensure they are not transferring excess capital. A clear methodology avoids disputes and protects cash flow on both sides.
Inventory valuation requires equal rigor. New vehicles usually transfer at invoice, while used vehicle valuation depends on market conditions and aging. Accurate reconciliation of parts, accessories, and prepaid items is essential. Buyers should closely assess inventory quality to avoid assuming aged or overpriced stock.
Floorplan financing also requires coordination. Payoff procedures, interest credits, and curtailment obligations should be specified in the purchase agreement. Buyers must ensure new credit facilities will be in place to support immediate operational needs.
OEM Approval and Transition Planning
OEM approval is often the most time-consuming element of a dealership transaction. Buyers must demonstrate financial capacity and operational expertise, while sellers should anticipate facility or image-program requirements that could affect timing or pricing. Early dialogue with the manufacturer helps avoid surprises.
Transition planning ensures continuity for employees and customers. Payroll, HR policies, technology systems, vendor agreements, and accounting processes require careful coordination. A defined transition period, often with limited seller involvement, helps retain key staff and maintain customer satisfaction.
Tax Planning and Post-Closing Requirements
Effective tax planning can substantially influence deal economics. Buyers should evaluate opportunities for bonus depreciation, cost segregation, and elections that enhance the tax efficiency of acquired assets. Sellers must understand capital gains exposure, depreciation recapture, and state tax implications to determine net proceeds.
Post-closing reconciliations, working capital adjustments, inventory true-ups, and prorated expenses, should be clearly defined in the purchase agreement. Detailed documentation and consistent methodologies help prevent disputes and allow each party to close the books efficiently.
The Road Ahead
Buying or selling a dealership requires financial discipline, operational insight, and strategic alignment. Owners and financial leaders who prepare thoroughly, and engage advisors experienced in dealership transactions, taxation, and OEM requirements, are better positioned to maximize value and minimize disruption. Thoughtful planning is essential to achieving strong outcomes in a rapidly evolving industry.
Author: Erika Gagne, CPA