Industry News

Winning the Technician Talent Battle: Why Investing in Your People Pays Off

Written by Albin, Randall & Bennett | Nov 19, 2026, 9:23:35 PM

For many dealerships, finding and retaining qualified service technicians has become one of the biggest challenges facing their operations. While dealerships regularly invest in facilities, equipment, and technology to improve efficiency and profitability, one of their most valuable investments is often overlooked: their people.

When variable operations margins face pressure, fixed operations become especially important to a dealership’s financial performance. A strong service department supports customer loyalty and provides an ongoing source of revenue. However, even the most advanced service facility cannot operate at its full potential without skilled technicians.

Recruiting, developing, and retaining qualified technicians should therefore be viewed as a long-term investment in dealership profitability rather than simply a staffing challenge. 

The True Cost of Technician Turnover

When an experienced technician leaves, the financial impact extends beyond the cost of finding a replacement. An unfilled position reduces service capacity and can mean fewer billable hours and longer customer wait times. Service managers spend time recruiting and training replacements, and new employees may take time to reach their predecessors’ productivity levels.

Consider a dealership that loses an experienced technician consistently producing 40 hours per week. At an effective labor rate of $150 per hour, that position represents approximately $6,000 in potential weekly labor sales. Even before considering associated parts sales, the lost gross is significant, especially if the vacancy goes out beyond a month. Coupled with recruiting fees and the indirect impact on efficiency, tech turnover can get expensive quickly and prevent your service department from operating to its potential.

Build a Recruiting Pipeline Before You Need One

Too often, recruiting begins only after an employee gives notice. By then, the dealership faces an immediate staffing need and may feel pressured to fill the position quickly rather than finding the right candidate.

Making recruiting an ongoing part of operations can help. Relationships with local technical schools, community colleges, and automotive training programs can establish a pipeline of future technicians. Apprenticeships and mentorship opportunities provide a path for less experienced employees to develop into productive service team members.

Equally important is demonstrating a clear path for advancement. Entry-level technicians should understand the training, certifications, and experience needed to progress into specialized or senior roles. Mentors also need sufficient time and support to train new employees effectively.

The goal should be to develop the workforce the dealership will need three to five years from now while addressing today’s vacancies.

Retention Starts on Day One

Recruiting a qualified technician is only half the battle. The employee experience begins during hiring and continues through onboarding, training, and everyday interactions with management.

Technicians want to feel supported, valued, and equipped to succeed. Poor communication, inadequate training, or unclear expectations can create frustration even when compensation is competitive. A structured onboarding process helps new hires understand their responsibilities and where to turn for assistance.

Service managers should conduct regular employee check-ins rather than waiting until someone resigns to identify concerns. Understanding what employees value and addressing problems early can help reduce turnover and build a more engaged workforce.

Compensation Is Only Part of the Equation

Competitive compensation is essential, but higher pay alone may not address the reasons employees leave. For technicians working under flat-rate compensation structures, consistent workflow and opportunities to produce billable hours can be just as important as the hourly rate.

Inefficient dispatching, parts delays, and scheduling problems can limit technician earnings while reducing dealership productivity. Simply adding technicians will not resolve those bottlenecks. Management should evaluate whether service demand, available work, equipment, and shop processes support the team’s productive capacity.

Before implementing significant pay increases, consider whether operational improvements could increase both technician earnings and dealership profitability. Benefits, predictable schedules, training opportunities, and shop conditions also matter when evaluating the overall compensation package and employee experience.

Investing in People Is Investing in Profitability

There is no single solution to the technician shortage, but dealerships can take a more deliberate approach to recruiting, developing, and retaining their service teams.

Management should regularly evaluate technician turnover, time to fill open positions, billable hours, productivity, and labor gross profit. Reviewing these measures together can help determine whether investments in training, compensation, and workflow improvements are producing meaningful results. Where performance falls short, management should identify whether staffing, demand, or operational constraints are responsible before committing additional resources.

Just as dealerships evaluate investments in facilities, equipment, and technology, they should consider the long-term return on investments in employees. A stable, productive service team helps maintain service capacity, support customer satisfaction, and drive long-term profitability.

Author: Cassidy Wood, CPA, Albin Randall & Bennett, an NHADA Silver Partner