On Nov. 9, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced a settlement with a New York used car dealership group accused of failing to include thousands of dollars in mandatory non-government fees in advertised prices. The settlement requires compliance reporting, monitoring and recordkeeping. Because the FTC did not bring the case jointly with the New York Attorney General, it could not obtain a monetary penalty, but violations of the settlement could result in civil penalties of $53,088 per violation.
The settlement follows the FTC’s March 13 announcement that it warned 97 dealerships of potentially illegal advertising practices. Both the warning letters and the FTC’s recently released Automobile Industry Pricing Transparency: FAQs emphasize that advertised prices must reflect what consumers actually pay, without hidden fees or charges added on top of what’s advertised. This is the FTC’s second settlement with a dealership group that has received a warning letter and the first involving a used car dealership group.
The FTC alleged that, despite receiving a warning letter in March, the dealership group continued charging consumers more than the advertised price by excluding dealer-imposed fees and add-on purchases from advertised prices, hiding charges in disclaimers and confirming advertised prices by phone without disclosing the full price until customers arrived at the dealership.
The FTC also alleged that the group charged a $175 “doc fee” without disclosing the fee was retained by the dealer and not required by law. New York allows dealers to charge up to $175 for fees but requires disclosure that the fee is not required by or paid to the DMV.
The settlement requires the dealership group to clearly and conspicuously advertise the vehicle’s total price as the most prominent price, including all mandatory fees or charges except those required by government. For third-party advertising, the group must provide the total price, request its prominent display, and take all reasonable steps in its control to ensure compliance. FTC settlements are only between the party and the FTC and are not an admission of guilt.
More Information: